
Iyalan wani mutum mai shekaru 77 -- wanda ya mutu bayan ya faɗi baya yayin da yake ƙoƙarin taka kan bene -- sun amince su sasanta ƙarar da suka shigar kan wani gidan hutu na Seaside da ta kai dala miliyan 4.3, kan ƙaramin adadin.
Iyalan David Lloyd Roach sun janye ƙarar da suka shigar domin a biya su dala 37,500. An shirya fara shari'ar farar hula a makon da ya gabata a Kotun Gundumar Multnomah.
Lauyan Salem Jeffrey Thayer ya ƙi yin tsokaci. Thayer ya wakilci gidan Roach da kuma 'ya'yansa maza biyu manya waɗanda suka kai ƙara a madadin gidan. Portland Lauyan Carl Rodrigues shi ma ya ƙi yin tsokaci. Ya wakilci Tides ta ƙungiyar masu mallakar Sea kuma manaja a lokacin Angie Hummell.
Roach, a Washington mazaunin, yana hayar gidaje da dama a gidan hutu mai rukunin gidaje 51 na bakin teku tare da matarsa, 'ya'yansa maza da sauran danginsa a watan Agusta na 2013. Sun kasance a wurin kwanaki da yawa lokacin da Roach ya yi ƙoƙarin taka daga ciyawa zuwa bene na ɗaya daga cikin rukunin. Bene ɗin yana da nisan inci 14 daga ƙasa.
Roach ya daka yatsansa a gefen benen saboda bai taka tsayin da ya kamata ba, bisa ga bayanin ɗaya daga cikin 'ya'yan Roach. Ya faɗi baya a ƙasa, yana bugun duwawunsa sannan ya bugi kansa.
Roach bai suma ba, ya ce yana lafiya. Amma a wani lokaci daga baya a ranar, ya ce yana jin tashin zuciya, sai ya fara amai. Iyalinsa sun kai shi ɗakin gaggawa na Seaside.
Roach ya yi fama da ciwon jini na subdural -- yana zubar jini kusa da kwakwalwarsa -- kuma an kai shi da jirgin sama zuwa Cibiyar Kiwon Lafiya ta St. Vincent a Portland, bisa ga takardun kotu da mai kare ya rubuta. Yana shiga da fita daga gidan kula da tsofaffi kuma Washington asibiti, kafin ya mutu a ranar 24 ga Nuwamba, 2013, saboda raunin da ya samu.
Karar ta zargi Tides by the Sea da manajanta da abin da ta yi ikirarin cewa babban lahani ne a tsarinta -- rashin sandunan hannu ko kuma shinge a kusa da benen da zai ba masu amfani damar shiga da sauka lafiya. Rundunar tsaron ta yi shirin kiran wani ƙwararre shaida wanda zai shaida cewa dokokin gini ba sa buƙatar shinge a kusa da irin wannan bene mai ƙasa.
Karar ta kuma zargi ƙungiyar gidaje da manajanta da sanya kujerun Adirondack a kan irin wannan ƙaramin bene -- wanda ya sa Roach ya yi ƙoƙarin zuwa ɗaya daga cikin kujerun daga gefen benen saboda babu isasshen sarari don yin tafiya a kan siraran benen.
A cewar masu kare lafiyar, benen yana da faɗin ƙafa 4-inci 4 da tsayin ƙafa 12.
A cikin takardun kotu da suka nemi alkali ya yi watsi da karar kafin a fara shari'ar, masu kare hakkin sun yi jayayya cewa Roach da iyalinsa sun yi hutu a Tides by the Sea akalla sau uku a cikin shekaru 10 da suka gabata kuma sun saba da benen. Akalla ɗaya daga cikin 'ya'yan Roach ya yi tunanin benen yana da haɗari amma bai sanar da sauran 'yan uwa game da hakan ba, in ji masu kare hakkin.
Lauyan gidan Roach ya yi jayayya cewa alhakin ƙirƙirar bene mai aminci ya rataya ne a wuyan Tides by the Sea, kuma ƙwararren mai ƙara ya shirya shaida cewa tsayin inci 14 daga ciyawa zuwa saman benen yana da haɗari.
An yi jayayya cewa da an iya magance matsalar ta hanyar ƙirƙirar wani mataki a duk faɗin gaban benen, kamar benen da ke kan raka'a a fadin farfajiyar.
A watan Satumba, Alkali Pro-tem Eric Neiman ya amince cewa ya kamata a gabatar da batun alhaki ga alkalai. Wannan ya haifar da sulhu a wannan watan. An tsara zaman shari'ar zai ɗauki kwanaki shida, kuma ya ƙare a wannan makon.
Karanta taƙaitaccen bayanin mai tsaron lamarinsa a nan.
Karanta mai ƙara taƙaitaccen bayani a nan.
Domin ƙarin bayani, bi wannan mahada.


