Hukumar farar hula ta 172020

Danna nan don sigar da za ta dace da bugawa.


Gabatarwa

A ranar 20 ga Oktoba, 2022, Kotun Koli ta Jihar Washington An yanke wani muhimmin hukunci da ke da nufin magance matsalar nuna wariya ta launin fata a shari'o'in kotunan farar hula. Henderson da Thompson, ya faɗaɗa kan irin wannan hukuncin daga Kotun wanda ya shafi shari'o'in kotunan laifuka (Duba: Jiha da Zamora).


Me ke faruwa game da wannan? Henderson shawara?

Kafin wannan hukuncin. Washington Dokokin kotu sun tabbatar da cewa alhakin wanda ke zargin ɓangaren don tabbatar da cewa nuna wariya ta launin fata ta rinjayi shari'o'in kotunan farar hula ko hukunce-hukuncen juri. Henderson hukuncin ya kammala da cewa idan wani ɓangare a shari'ar farar hula ya zargi wani ɓangare da son zuciya, alhakin wanda ake zargi don tabbatar da cewa babu irin wannan son zuciya. Wannan babban sauyi ne domin yana canza nauyin daga "tabbatar da sakamakon ya kasance na launin fata" zuwa "tabbatar da cewa ba haka bane".


Bayani ga Henderson da Thompson harka:

Ta yaya ya fara?  A wannan shari'ar, Janelle Henderson, wata bakar fata, da Alicia Thompson, wata farar fata, sun shiga cikin hatsarin mota. Thompson ta amince da laifin hatsarin amma ba ta yi tayin biyan diyya ga Henderson ba saboda raunin da ta samu. Henderson ta yi ikirarin cewa yanayin da take ciki ya kara ta'azzara sakamakon hatsarin kuma ta kai kara kotu don neman diyya.

Me ya faru a shari'ar?  A lokacin shari'ar, ƙungiyar kare Thomson ta soki sahihancin Henderson da lauyanta - wacce ita ma baƙar fata ce - ta hanyar amfani da kalmomin wariyar launin fata da kuma nuna rashin da'a tsakanin Henderson da shaidunta Baƙar fata.

Me alkalan suka yanke?  Masu yanke hukunci sun mayar da hukuncin dala $9,200 kacal ga Henderson.

Yaya Henderson ya amsa?  Henderson ya koma wata sabuwar gwaji ko kuma ƙarin bayani (wanda kotun ta ayyana a matsayin ƙarin hukuncin da juri ya yanke na diyya wanda kotun ta ga bai isa ba) bisa dalilin cewa ƙarar da aka yi ta yi kan nuna wariya ta launin fata ta shafi hukuncin.

Ta yaya kotun shari'a ta mayar da martani ga buƙatar Henderson?  Kotun da aka shigar da ƙara ba ta ma ba da damar sauraron ƙarar ba. Maimakon haka, kotun ta ce ba za ta iya "buƙatar lauyoyi su guji amfani da kalmomin da suka shafi shaidar da ke cikin shari'ar ba, koda kuwa a wasu yanayi harshen yana da alaƙa da launin fata."


Menene muhimman abubuwan da Kotun Koli ta WA ta yanke a cikin Henderson?

a cikin Henderson hukuncin, Washington Kotun Koli ta Jiha ta yanke hukuncin cewa Henderson ya yi amfani da CR 59(a)(9) yadda ya kamata, wanda ya ce hukuncin da aka yanke wanda wariyar launin fata ta shafa bai dace da babban adalci ba kuma yana buƙatar sabon shari'a.

Bugu da ƙari, Kotun ta yanke hukunci cewa "[idan] mai ƙarar farar hula ya nuna isasshiyar hujjar nuna wariya ta launin fata a ƙarƙashin wannan ƙa'ida, kotu tilas bayar da sauraron shaidu domin tantance ko akwai buƙatar wani sabon shari'a" (An ƙara jaddadawa.) Henderson, 19. Ta kuma yanke hukunci cewa wajen tantance ko ya kamata a bayar da shaidar, ba nufin wanda ake tuhuma ko kuma shawarar kotu cewa akwai iya a yi amfani da wasu hanyoyin daban na nuna bambancin launin fata a cikin wannan shawarar.

A ƙarshe, Kotun ta yanke hukuncin cewa a wannan zaman sauraron ƙarar, "kotun da aka shigar za ta ɗauka cewa nuna wariya ga launin fata ya shafi hukuncin, kuma ɓangaren da ke cin gajiyar zargin nuna wariya ga launin fata yana da alhakin tabbatar da cewa ya aikata hakan. ba. " Henderson, mai shekaru 19.


Waɗanne irin "ƙarfe-ƙarfe na nuna wariya ga launin fata" ne Kotu ta amince da su a shari'ar Henderson?

  • Lauyan Thompson ya yi ta bayyana Henderson a matsayin "mai jayayya da kuma "mai fafutuka" a cikin shaidarta. Kotun ta amince cewa waɗannan sharuɗɗan "suna haifar da mummunan ra'ayi na 'mace Baƙar fata mai fushi'." Henderson,
  • Lauyan Thompson ya sha kwatanta wannan halayyar Henderson da Thompson, wanda ta bayyana a matsayin "mai tsoro da motsin rai".
  • A cikin muhawarar ƙarshe, lauyan Thompson ya yi nuni da ra'ayoyin wariyar launin fata game da mata Baƙar fata a matsayin waɗanda ba a yarda da su ba kuma sha'awar samun wata hanyar samun kuɗi da ba a samu ba ta motsa su. Lauyan Thompson ya yi jayayya cewa Henderson yana ƙara gishiri ko ƙirƙira raunin da ya same ta. Kotun ta yanke hukuncin cewa wannan hujja ta haifar da ra'ayoyi marasa kyau da na ƙarya game da mata Baƙar fata marasa aminci, lalaci, yaudara, da kuma kwadayi. Henderson,
  • Lauyan Thompson ya bayyana shaidar shaidun Baƙar fata guda uku na Henderson a matsayin "babban son zuciya".
  • Lauyan Thompson ya yi ikirarin cewa shaidun Baƙar fata sun haɗu don yin ƙarya ga mai ƙarar Baƙar fata. Henderson,
  • Lauyan Thompson ya ba da shawarar cewa Henderson yana da wata dangantaka mara kyau da likitanta na chiropractic wanda zai sa ya yi mata ƙarya. Henderson,
  • Alkalin da ke shari'ar Henderson ya ce alkalan sun bukaci Henderson ya fita daga kotun kafin su fita daga dakin alkalan don yanke hukunci.

Idan na yi zargin cewa nuna wariya ta launin fata na yin mummunan tasiri ga shari'ar abokin cinikina, me zan yi? Yaya tsarin yake?

Sauƙi: Kawo shi ga kotun.  Nauyin shaida yana kan wanda ake zargi, wanda dole ne ya tabbatar da cewa babu nuna wariya ta launin fata.


Kammalawa

Wannan hukuncin ya daɗe yana zuwa. Akwai lokutta da yawa a cikin shekarun da lauyoyi ke ɗaukaka ƙara kan nuna wariya ga launin fata (kuma wani lokacin alkalai suna bin sa) ba tare da sun fito kai tsaye sun faɗi haka ba. Sun yi amfani da shi (kamar a cikin Henderson) wasu kalmomi da kuma yin wasu zarge-zarge waɗanda suka sa ya yi wa ɗayan ɓangaren wahala ya tabbatar da manufar da ke bayansu. Yanzu da nauyin ya canza, duk da haka, zai sa ya zama da wuya a sami ƙarin hujjoji game da nuna wariya ga launin fata, kuma idan suka yi, za a fallasa su kuma za a ɗauki alhakin mai laifin. Wannan nasara ce ba ga mutanen launin fata kawai ba, har ma ga duk wanda ya tsaya tsayin daka don tabbatar da adalci a cikin wannan shari'ar. Washington tsarin kotunan jiha.


Mai bada gudummawa

Don ƙarin bayani kan batutuwan da aka tattauna a cikin wannan sabuntawar doka, da fatan za a tuntuɓi marubucin:

James Goodyin  Lauya |
Mai hannun jari a GLP Lawyers

206.448.1992  |  Danna nan don ƙarin koyo game da Jamus.


Disclaimer

Bayanin da ke cikin wannan sabuntawa an bayar da shi ne kawai don dalilai na bayanai. Da fatan za a tuntuɓi lauyanku don neman shawara kan kowace takamaiman al'amari na shari'a.