Nyumba Yamalamulo 172020

Dinani apa kuti mupeze mtundu wosavuta kusindikiza.


Introduction

Pa Okutobala 20, 2022, Khoti Lalikulu la Boma la Washington yapereka chigamulo chofunika kwambiri chomwe cholinga chake ndi kuthana ndi nkhani ya tsankho la mafuko m'makhothi a anthu wamba. Chigamulochi, Henderson v. Thompson, ikufotokozanso za chigamulo chofanana ndi cha Khoti chomwe chinagwiritsidwa ntchito pa milandu ya milandu (Onani: Boma v. Zamora).


Chatsopano ndi chiyani pa Henderson chisankho?

Chigamulochi chisanachitike, Washington Malamulo a khoti adatsimikiza kuti ndi udindo wa chipani chotsutsa kutsimikizira kuti tsankho la fuko linakhudza milandu ya anthu wamba kapena zigamulo za oweruza milandu. Mosiyana ndi zimenezi, Henderson Chigamulochi chimatsimikiza kuti pamene munthu amene ali m'nkhani ya milandu ya anthu akuimba mlandu wina kuti ndi wokondera, ndi udindo wa chipani choimbidwa mlandu kutsimikizira kuti panalibe tsankho lotere. Uku ndi kusintha kwakukulu chifukwa kumachotsa udindo kuchoka pa "kutsimikizira kuti zotsatira zake zinali za tsankho" kupita ku "kutsimikizira kuti sizinali".


Mbiri ya Henderson v. Thompson mlandu:

Zinayamba bwanji?  Pankhaniyi, Janelle Henderson, mkazi wakuda, ndi Alicia Thompson, mkazi woyera, adakhudzidwa ndi ngozi ya galimoto. Thompson adavomereza kuti ndi amene adayambitsa ngoziyo koma sanapereke chipukuta misozi kwa Henderson chifukwa cha kuvulala kwake. Henderson adati vuto lake lomwe linalipo kale linali lalikulu kwambiri chifukwa cha ngoziyo ndipo adasumira mlandu kuti amulipire ndalama.

Kodi chinachitika n’chiyani pa mlandu?  Pa nthawi ya mlanduwu, gulu la oteteza la Thomson linatsutsa kudalirika kwa Henderson ndi loya wake - yemwenso anali mkazi wakuda - m'mawu omwe ankatchula za tsankho ndipo anasonyeza kuti Henderson ndi mboni zake zakuda analibe khalidwe loyenera.

Kodi oweruza milandu anasankha chiyani?  Oweruza milandu adapereka chigamulo cha $9,200 chokha kwa Henderson.

Kodi Henderson anayankha bwanji?  Henderson wasankha kuti akayesedwenso kapena chowonjezera (kufotokozedwa ngati kuwonjezeredwa kwa chiwongola dzanja ndi khoti la oweruza milandu zomwe khotilo likuona kuti sizokwanira) pachifukwa chakuti apilo obwerezabwereza okhudza tsankho la mafuko adakhudza chigamulocho.

Kodi khoti loyamba linayankha bwanji pempho la Henderson?  Khoti loyamba silinapereke ngakhale umboni wokhudza pempholi. M'malo mwake, khotilo linanena kuti silingathe "kukakamiza maloya kuti asamagwiritse ntchito mawu okhudzana ndi umboni womwe uli mu mlanduwu, ngakhale kuti nthawi zina chilankhulocho chimakhala ndi mitundu yosiyanasiyana."


Kodi mfundo zazikulu zomwe Khoti Lalikulu la WA linapereka ndi ziti? Henderson?

Mu Henderson chisankho, Washington Khoti Lalikulu la Boma linagamula kuti Henderson adagwiritsa ntchito moyenera CR 59(a)(9), yomwe imanena kuti chigamulo chomwe chakhudzidwa ndi tsankho la mafuko sichigwirizana ndi chilungamo chachikulu ndipo chimafuna kuti mlandu watsopano uyambe.

Komanso, Khotilo linagamula kuti “[ngati] wotsutsa milandu ya anthu apanga chithunzithunzi chokwanira chosonyeza tsankho la mafuko motsatira muyezo uwu, khotilo ayenela perekani msonkhano wokhudza umboni kuti mudziwe ngati mlandu watsopano ukuyenera kuweruzidwa” (Kutsindika kwawonjezeredwa.) Henderson, 19. Linagamulanso kuti posankha ngati mlandu wa umboni uyenera kuperekedwa, zolinga za wotsutsa mlanduyo kapena lingaliro la khoti loti palibe ndikanathera pakhale kutanthauzira kwina kwa nkhani ya khalidwe lochokera ku tsankho pa chisankho chimenecho.

Pomaliza pake, Khotilo linagamula kuti pamlanduwu, "khoti loyamba liyenera kuganiza kuti tsankho la fuko linakhudza chigamulocho, ndipo chipani chomwe chikupindula ndi tsankho la fuko chomwe chikunenedwa kuti chili ndi udindo wotsimikizira kuti chinatero." osati. " Henderson, wazaka 19.


Kodi ndi mitundu iti ya "madandaulo okhudza tsankho la mafuko" omwe Khotilo linavomereza kuti adachitika pa mlandu wa Henderson?

  • Loya wa Thompson mobwerezabwereza anafotokoza Henderson ngati "wokangana komanso "wotsutsana" mu umboni wake. Khotilo linavomereza kuti mawu awa "akubweretsa malingaliro oipa a 'mkazi wakuda wokwiya'." Henderson,
  • Loya wa Thompson mobwerezabwereza anasiyanitsa khalidwe la Henderson ndi la Thompson, yemwe anamutcha kuti "wochita mantha komanso wamaganizo".
  • Pomaliza, loya wa Thompson adatchula malingaliro otsutsana okhudza kusankhana mitundu okhudza akazi Akuda ngati osadalirika ndipo adalimbikitsidwa ndi chikhumbo chofuna kupeza ndalama zomwe sanazigwiritse ntchito. Loya wa Thompson adati Henderson anali kukokomeza kapena kunamizira kuvulala kwake. Khotilo linagamula kuti mfundo imeneyi idapangitsa kuti pakhale malingaliro oipa komanso abodza okhudza akazi Akuda kukhala osadalirika, aulesi, achinyengo, komanso adyera. Henderson,
  • Loya wa Thompson anafotokoza kuti umboni wa mboni zitatu zakuda za Henderson ndi “wokondera mwachibadwa”.
  • Loya wa Thompson adati mboni zakuda zidagwirizana kuti zinene bodza m'malo mwa wodandaula wakuda. Henderson,
  • Loya wa Thompson adanena kuti Henderson anali ndi ubale wosayenera ndi chiropractor wake zomwe zikanamupangitsa kuti amunyengerere. Henderson,
  • Woweruza milandu ya Henderson adati oweruza milanduwo akufuna kuti Henderson achoke m'khoti asanatuluke m'chipinda choweruza milandu kuti akapereke chigamulo chawo.

Ngati ndikukayikira kuti tsankho la mtundu likukhudza mlandu wa kasitomala wanga, ndiyenera kuchita chiyani? Kodi ndondomekoyi ikuwoneka bwanji?

Zosavuta: Uzani khoti.  Udindo wopereka umboni uli m'manja mwa woimbidwa mlanduyo, yemwe ayenera kutsimikizira kuti panalibe tsankho la mafuko.


Kutsiliza

Chigamulochi chinali cha nthawi yayitali. Pakhala zochitika zambiri m'zaka zambiri pomwe maloya adapempha tsankho la mafuko (ndipo nthawi zina oweruza milandu amavomereza) popanda kunena mwachindunji. Agwiritsa ntchito (monga mu Henderson) mawu enaake ndi kupereka zifukwa zina zomwe zinapangitsa kuti zikhale zovuta kwa winayo kutsimikizira cholinga chawo. Komabe, popeza kuti vutoli lasintha, zipangitsa kuti zikhale zovuta kwambiri kuti kufunsira tsankho la mafuko kuchitike, ndipo akatero, adzawonekera poyera ndipo wolakwayo adzaimbidwa mlandu. Ichi ndi chigonjetso osati kwa anthu amitundu yokha, komanso kwa aliyense amene amateteza chilungamo m'malo mwa Washington dongosolo la makhothi a boma.


Wopereka

Kuti mudziwe zambiri pa mitu yomwe ikukambidwa mu zosintha zamalamulo izi, chonde musazengereze kulumikizana ndi wolemba wake:

James GoodIng  | Loya
Wogawana nawo magawo ku GLP Attorneys

206.448.1992  |  Dinani apa kuti mudziwe zambiri zokhudza James.


chandalama

Chidziwitso chomwe chili mu zosinthazi chaperekedwa kuti chidziwitse anthu okha. Chonde funsani loya wanu kuti mupeze upangiri pa nkhani iliyonse yazamalamulo.