By Conner Shultz | Loia o le Aufaigaluega | Loia a le GLP in Seattle, Washington

Beginning October 18, 2026, insurers may still use billing databases, but a database alone cannot substitute for a reasonable investigation.

Mo le toatele Washington tausi soifua maloloina, one of the most frustrating developments in automobile insurance over the past two years has been the reduction of medical bills based on a computer-generated benchmark rather than the circumstances of the patient’s care.

The practice received significant legal support in 2024, when the Washington Supreme Court decided Schiff v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co., 2 Wn.3d 762, 542 P.3d 1002 (2024). O lenei, o le Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner has adopted new claims-handling rules that substantially change the regulatory landscape.

The new rules do not prohibit insurers from using databases such as FAIR Health to evaluate medical charges. They do, however, make one point clear: an insurer cannot rely solely on a database when deciding to deny or refuse to pay all or part of a claim.

I. How We Got Here: Schiff e faasaga ia Liberty Mutual

vaʻa involved Liberty Mutual’s use of the FAIR Health database to evaluate medical bills submitted under Personal Injury Protection, or PIP, coverage. FAIR Health allows insurers to compare charges for particular services within a geographic area and identify percentile benchmarks. Under Liberty Mutual’s methodology, charges at or below the 80th percentile were paid in full, while charges above that benchmark were reduced.

le Washington Supreme Court ruled in Liberty Mutual’s favor. The Court concluded that comparing charges for the same treatment in the same geographic area is relevant to determining reasonableness and held that Liberty Mutual’s use of FAIR Health and its 80th-percentile methodology was not, on that record, unfair or unreasonable under Washington tulafono.

The practical impact was significant. Following vaʻa, providers increasingly encountered PIP reductions based on FAIR Health or similar statistical benchmarks.

Justice Debra Stephens identified the central concern in her dissent. She agreed that billing databases could be useful, but questioned whether a database alone could establish that a particular provider’s charge was unreasonable. As she observed, a patient may incur a reasonable medical expense even if that expense exceeds the 80th-percentile benchmark.

Washington’s new rules now directly address that issue.

II. A Database Cannot Be the Entire Investigation

On August 18, 2026, the Office of the Insurance Commissioner adopted amendments to Washington’s claims-handling regulations that take effect October 18, 2026.

The provision most important to PIP providers is amended WAC 284-30-330(4). The rule continues to prohibit insurers from denying or refusing to pay claims, in whole or in part, without conducting a reasonable investigation. It now adds:

“A reasonable investigation may not rely solely on the use of a database.”

The rule expressly includes estimating software and benchmarks gathered from one or multiple databases.

That language is important because it addresses the central feature of the bill-review process at issue in vaʻa: reliance on a database as the basis for reducing a medical charge.

The change does not mean insurers must automatically pay every bill in full. Nor does it prohibit the use of FAIR Health or other databases. An insurer may still use market data as part of its investigation.

What changes is that a percentile, algorithm, or database benchmark cannot be the insurer’s entire investigation when it decides not to pay all or part of a claim.

III. The Insurer Remains Responsible

The new regulations also reinforce that insurers remain responsible for the evaluations used to determine what is owed under an insurance policy.

Teuteuga WAC 284-30-380(7) provides that insurers are responsible for the accuracy of their evaluations, including evaluations performed on their behalf, when determining amounts owed under the policy.

That matters when carriers outsource bill review to third-party vendors or rely on outside software. The fact that another company generated the evaluation does not relieve the insurer of responsibility for the result.

The Office of the Insurance Commissioner described this obligation during the rulemaking process as a nondelegable duty.

IV. Existing PIP Protections Still Apply

Washington’s existing PIP rules also remain important.

i lalo WAC 284-30-395, an insurer may deny, limit, or terminate PIP medical benefits only if the services are not reasonable, not necessary, not related to the accident, or were not incurred within three years of the accident.

When an insurer decides to deny or limit benefits, it must provide a written explanation describing the reasons for its decision. Simply stating that treatment was “not reasonable or necessary” is insufficient. If the insurer consults a healthcare professional, that reviewer generally must practice in the same health field or specialty as the treating provider.

The new database rule adds another layer of protection to that framework.

V. What Providers Should Watch For

When a PIP payment is reduced, providers should preserve the explanation of benefits and any correspondence identifying the basis for the reduction.

If the insurer cites FAIR Health, another database, a “usual and customary” charge, or a percentile benchmark, the important question after October 18 is not simply, “What database did the insurer use?” It is, “What else did the insurer actually investigate before deciding that this particular charge should not be paid?”

Providers should also continue documenting treatment and charges carefully. Accurate coding, complete records, clear treatment plans, and documentation supporting the necessity and reasonableness of care remain important whenever an insurer questions a medical bill.

If a patient is being balance billed because PIP reduced a charge, involving the patient’s attorney early may also help ensure the insurer is required to explain and support the basis for its decision.

VI. vaʻa Is Not Gone, But the Rules Have Changed

The new regulations do not overrule vaʻa. le Washington Supreme Court’s decision remains good law.

Ae afea vaʻa was decided in 2024, WAC 284-30-330 required a reasonable investigation without expressly saying that an insurer could not rely solely on a database. Beginning October 18, 2026, it will.

That is an important change for healthcare providers and their patients.

Insurers may continue using technology and market data to assist in reviewing PIP medical bills. But Washington’s new rules make clear that the insurer, not an algorithm, remains responsible for determining what the policy actually owes.

And when an insurer decides not to pay a medical bill in full, a database result alone is no longer enough. If your patient is experiencing PIP bill reductions or other insurance-related barriers to care, GLP Attorneys is here to help.

Talanoa i se Tagata Poto Masani Washington Loia mo Manu'aga Fa'aletagata i le Aso

Loia a le GLP is here to help you navigate your insurance coverage and medical claims after an faalavelave tau taavale. Personal injury cases from automobiles can be complex, and the Washington personal injury lawyers at GLP Attorneys are here to help you understand and navigate insurance coverage issues, including Personal Injury Protection coverage, to ensure you receive a just outcome.

GLP Attorneys has decades of experience representing individuals and families injured in car accidents across the Pacific Northwest. Our personal injury lawyers serving the Pacific Northwest provide trusted guidance and strong advocacy to help clients move forward after serious injuries.

If you have been injured in an automobile accident and are navigating complex insurance claims, please call (800) 273-5005 pe imeli mai i a matou loia mo manu'aga patino i le mo se fa'atalanoaga muamua e leai se totogi.

About Conner Shultz, Seattle Le tagata lava ia Manua Loia

Conner Shultz is a Staff Attorney in GLP Attorneys' Seattle office, where he is committed to pursuing justice for those harmed through no fault of their own. Prior to admittance to the Washington State Bar in 2025, Conner spent several years working as a paralegal in personal injury law. He first joined the firm as an intern in 2023, gaining meaningful experience and insight into the firm’s mission of delivering exceptional service and results. Conner is a WSAJ Eagle Member.