John D. Webber, ane mugoveri paGraham Lundberg Peschel, akawana mari inosvika mamiriyoni maviri emadhora ($2 miriyoni) yeJames A. Chamness, mugari weSnohomish County, akakuvara zvakaipisisa mutsaona yematanda muna 2010 muSkagit County. Takadada kumiririra VaChamness uye kuvabatsira kuti vagadzirire kudzoka kwavo kuhupenyu. Tinoda kugovera nyaya yavo muchidimbu.

ZVINHU ZVETSAONA

Musi wa13 Gumiguru, 2010, James Chamness aishanda semucheki wematanda kuHornbeck Cutting, Inc., panzvimbo yekucheka miti inonzi "Deers Danger CH" muSkagit County. WashingtonFrank Harkness Trucking & Logging, LLC, uyo aishanda semugadziri wezvinhu, akabhadhara Hornbeck kuti acheke matanda panzvimbo yeDeers Danger. Harkness akanga awana Chibvumirano cheBasa reKukohwa nekambani iyi. Washington Dhipatimendi reZviwanikwa zveMusikirwo rinounganidza, kubvisa nekuendesa matanda kubva panzvimbo ine njodzi yeDeers.

VaChamness nemumwe wavanoshanda naye vaicheka matanda nenguva dza12:45 manheru, uye vakanga vava kuda kupedza basa rezuva iroro. Mushandi pamwe chete naye akacheka muti wekupedzisira wakadonha ndokurova VaChamness, achipwanya divi rekurudyi remuviri wavo muvhu zvikakonzera kukuvara kwakanyanya uye kusingaperi. VaChamness vakavharirwa pasi pemuti wakatemwa kwemaawa vasati vaburitswa nevashandi vekurapa vekukurumidzira.

Sheriff weSkagit County nevashandi vekurapa kwekukurumidzira vaifanira kuita basa rakaoma rekutakura VaChamness mamita mazana matatu vachikwira daro rakakwira kusvika kunzvimbo yaigona kuiswa mumotokari. Vakazotakurwa kuenda kunzvimbo yaigona kumhara nehelikopta ndokuvatakura kuenda kuHarborviewMedicalCenter mu Seattle.

Pfupiso Pfupi yeMakuvara Akasiyana-siyana Anoremadza Muviri

James Chamness murume anoshamisa uye hupenyu hwake hahuzombofi hwakafanana mushure mezviitiko zvinotyisa zvakaitika musi wa13 Gumiguru 2010. Akapedza kudzidza paArlingtonHigh School muna 1988, uye akabva aenda kubasa muindasitiri yekucheka matanda, basa raakashanda kusvika panguva yetsaona musi wa13 Gumiguru 2010. VaChamness vakakuvara zvakanyanya, zvisingaperi zvaisanganisira:

  • Kutyoka kwehuremu yekurudyi
  • Pelvic kuputsika
  • Ronda rakavhurika remagaro
  • Ronda rakavhurika rehudyu nepahudyu rekurudyi
  • Kuchekwa kwegumbo rerudyi pasi pebvi nekuvhiyiwa kasere uye kuiswa kweprosthetic
  • Dambudziko rekugadzirisa nekuzvidya mwoyo
  • Kukuvara kwe brachial plexus yekurudyi,
  • Kukuvara kweruoko rwerudyi rwakanyanya kuburikidza nekuvhiyiwa kakawanda kuyedza kuponesa ruoko. Akarasikirwa nebasa reruoko rwake rwepamusoro rwerudyi zvizere, uye angada kuchekwa rutivi rwerudyi.

Nyaya dzeKufukidzwa kweInishuwarenzi neMutoro 

Chinhu chikuru chakaita kuti GLP ibudirire panyaya iyi kwaive kugona kwedu kutsvaga nekushandisa mitemo yakaoma maererano nemhosva yetsaona dzebasa pamwe nemitemo ine chekuita nekushandiswa kwehuwandu hwakawanda hweinishuwarenzi yemhosva yekurasikirwa kukuru, seyatakaunzwa nenyaya yaVaChamness.

pasi Washington Nyaya yeDare Repamusorosoro re Stute v. PMBC, 114 Wn.2d 454, 788 P.2d 545 (1990), kontrakita mukuru (munyaya iyi Frank Harkness Trucking & Logging) aive nebasa rekuchengetedza panzvimbo yebasa risingapiwi basa uye ane mutoro wekupedzisira wekuchengetedza basa uye hutano panzvimbo yebasa. Harkness aishanda semukontrakita mukuru panzvimbo yeDeers Danger pasi pe Stute ongororo ("Stute mutemo”).

GLP yakakwanisa kuona kuti mutemo weStute waishanda munyaya iyi nekuratidza kuti Washington matare edzimhosva akawedzera mutemo uyu kupfuura makambani makuru kusvika kune mamwe mapato akafanana zvakakwana zvekuti anokodzera kuisa mutoro wepamutemo.

Takanzwa kuti Harkness yaive neinishuwarenzi yemhosva shoma yemadhora miriyoni imwe chete. Paive neinishuwarenzi yemhosva yechipiri yaiwanikwa kuburikidza neHornbeck Cutting. Takakwanisa kuwana imwe mari inosvika miriyoni imwe chete yemadhora pasi pemutemo wechibvumirano cheinishuwarenzi uye chibvumirano chekuripira inishuwarenzi chakasainwa pakati paHarkness naHornbeck. Mari yese yemadhora mamiriyoni maviri yaimiririra miganhu yese yepolicy iripo.