Dzvanya pano kuti uwane shanduro inodhindwa zviri nyore.
ziviso
Musi wa20 Gumiguru, 2022, Dare Repamusorosoro reNyika ye Washington vakapa chisarudzo chakakosha chakanangana nekugadzirisa nyaya yerusaruraganda mumatare edzimhosva. Chisarudzo ichi, Henderson v. Thompson, inowedzera mutongo wakafanana newakabva kuDare waishanda kumatare edzimhosva (Ona: Hurumende v. Zamora).
Chii chitsva nezve Henderson chisarudzo?
Pamberi pemutongo uyu, Washington mitemo yedare yakaramba ichiti ibasa re bato rinopomera kuratidza kuti rusaruraganda rwakapesvedzera kutongwa kwematare edzimhosva kana kutongwa nedare redzimhosva. Kusiyana neizvi, Henderson Mutongo unogumisa kuti kana bato riri mumatare edzimhosva rikapomera rimwe bato mhosva yerusaruro, ibasa re bato riri kupomerwa mhosva kuratidza kuti pakanga pasina rusaruro rwakadaro. Uku kuchinja kukuru nekuti kunochinja mutoro kubva pa "kuratidza kuti mhedzisiro yacho yaikonzerwa nerusaruraganda" kuenda pa "kuratidza kuti yakanga isiri".
Nhoroondo yezvakaitika kare Henderson v. Thompson nyaya:
Zvakatanga sei? Munyaya iyi, Janelle Henderson, mukadzi mutema, naAlicia Thompson, mukadzi muchena, vakaroverana nemotokari. Thompson akabvuma mhosva yetsaona iyi asi haana kupa Henderson mari yekukuvara kwake. Henderson akati mamiriro ake ezvinhu akawedzera zvakanyanya netsaona iyi uye akamhan'arira mari yekukuvara.
Chii chakaitika mudare? Munguva yekutongwa, timu yaThomson yaidzivirira yakashora kuvimbika kwaHenderson negweta rake - zvakare mukadzi mutema - mumutauro waishora rusaruraganda uye wairatidza kusarongeka pakati paHenderson nezvapupu zvake zvitema.
Dare revatongi rakasarudza chii? Dare redzimhosva rakapa Henderson mutongo we$9,200 chete.
Henderson akapindura sei? Henderson akatamira kune imwe kutongwa kana chiwedzero (zvinotsanangurwa sekuwedzera kwemubhadharo wedare wemuripo wedare wemuripo uyo dare rinoona seusina kukwana) pachinzvimbo chekuti kukwidza nyaya kakawanda pamusoro perusarura rwerudzi kwakakanganisa mutongo.
Dare redzimhosva rakapindura sei chikumbiro chaHenderson? Dare redzimhosva harina kutombobvumidza kunzwa kweuchapupu pachikumbiro ichocho. Asi dare rakati harigone "kukumbira magweta kuti arege kushandisa mutauro wakabatana neuchapupu huri munyaya yacho, kunyangwe mune dzimwe nzvimbo mutauro wacho uine hunhu hwerudzi."
Ndezvipi zvinhu zvakakosha zvakapihwa mutongo weDare Repamusorosoro reWA muna Henderson?
Mu Henderson chisarudzo, Washington Dare Repamusorosoro reNyika rakatonga kuti Henderson akange ashandisa zvakakodzera CR 59(a)(9), iyo inoti mutongo unokanganiswa nerusaruraganda hauenderane neruramisiro yakakura uye unoda kutongwa patsva.
Uyezve, Dare rakatonga kuti “[kana] mukwikwidzi wenyaya dzezvematongerwo enyika akaita chitarisiko chekutanga chakakwana kuti ape fungidziro yerusarura rwerudzi pasi pemutemo uyu, dare fanira kupa mvumo yekunzwa kweuchapupu kuti vaone kana kutongwa kutsva kwakakodzera” (Kusimbiswa kwakawedzerwa.) Henderson, 19. Yakatongawo kuti pakusarudza kana nyaya yeuchapupu inofanira kunzwiwa, zvinangwa zvemupomerwi kana kuti pfungwa yedare yekuti pane Aizoita pave nekutsanangurwa kwakasiyana kwenyaya yetsika ine chekuita nerudzi musarudzo iyoyo.
Pakupedzisira, Dare rakatonga kuti pakutongwa ikoko, "dare redzimhosva rinofanira kufungidzira kuti rusaruraganda rwakakanganisa mutongo, uye bato riri kubatsirwa nerusaruraganda rwunonzi rwakaita kuti rusaruraganda ruve nebasa rekuratidza kuti rwakazviita." kwete. " Henderson, ane makore gumi nemapfumbamwe.
Ndedzipi mhando dze "kukwidza nyaya dzerusarura" idzo Dare rakabvuma kuti dzakaitika munyaya yaHenderson?
- Gweta raThompson rakagara richitsanangura Henderson semunhu “anokakavadzana uye “anorwa” muuchapupu hwake. Dare rakabvuma kuti mazwi aya “anoratidza pfungwa inokuvadza yekuti ‘mukadzi mutema ane hasha’.” Henderson,
- Gweta raThompson rakaramba richisiyanisa hunhu hwaHenderson naThompson, waakatsanangura se "anotya uye ane pfungwa".
- Mukutaura kwekupedzisira, gweta raThompson rakataura nezvepfungwa dzerusaruraganda pamusoro pevakadzi vatema sedzisina kuvimbika uye dzichikurudzirwa nechido chekuwana mari isina kubhadharwa. Gweta raThompson rakataura kuti Henderson aiwedzeredza kana kuti ainyepera kukuvara kwake. Dare rakati nharo iyi yairatidza pfungwa dzisina kunaka uye dzenhema pamusoro pevakadzi vatema sevasina kuvimbika, vane usimbe, vanonyengera, uye vane makaro. Henderson,
- Gweta raThompson rakatsanangura humbowo hwezvapupu zvitatu zvevatema zvaHenderson se "hwakasiyana-siyana".
- Gweta raThompson rakataura kuti zvapupu zvevatema zvakabatana kuti zvireve nhema kumunhu aipomerwa mhosva yemutema. Henderson,
- Gweta raThompson rakataura kuti Henderson aive neukama husina kunaka nechiropractor yake izvo zvaizoita kuti akwanise kunyepa nekuda kwake. Henderson,
- Mutongi wedare reHenderson akati dare raida kuti Henderson abude mudare vasati vabuda mukamuri redare kuti vape mutongo wavo.
Kana ndikafungidzira kuti rusaruraganda rwuri kukanganisa nyaya yemutengi wangu, ndoita sei? Maitiro acho akaita sei?
Zviri nyore: Zviise kudare. Mutoro wekupa humbowo uri pamunhu ari kupomerwa mhosva, uyo anofanira kuratidza kuti pakanga pasina rusaruro rwerudzi.
mhedziso
Mutongo uyu waive watora nguva yakareba uchiuya. Kwave nezviitiko zvakawanda mumakore apfuura apo magweta aikwidza nyaya yekusarura kwerudzi (uye dzimwe nguva vatongi vaibvumirana nazvo) vasina kubuda pachena vachitaura izvozvo. Vakashandisa (sezviri mu Henderson) mamwe mazwi uye vakapa dzimwe mhosva dzakaita kuti zviomere mumwe munhu kuratidza chinangwa chavo. Zvino zvachinja mutoro, zvisinei, zvichaita kuti zvisanyanya kuitika kuti nyaya dzerusaruraganda dziitike, uye padzichaitika, dzichaburitswa pachena uye mutadzi achazvidavirira. Uku kukunda kwete kwevanhu vemavara chete, asi kune chero ani zvake anomiririra kururamisira mu Washington hurongwa hwedare renyika.
Mupiro
Kuti uwane rumwe ruzivo nezvenyaya dziri kukurukurwa muchirongwa ichi chemutemo, ndapota musazeza kubata munyori wacho:
James Goodra Gweta |
Muridzi wemasheya kuGLP Attorneys
206.448.1992 | Dzvanya pano kuti udzidze zvakawanda nezvaJames.
Disclaimer
Ruzivo rwuri muchinyorwa chino rwunongopihwa chete kuti ruwane ruzivo. Ndapota taurai negweta renyu kuti muwane mazano panyaya ipi zvayo yemutemo.
