I-Civil 172020

Cofa apha ukuze ufumane inguqulelo elungele ukuprintwa.


intshayelelo

Ngomhla wama-20 kweyeDwarha ngowama-2022, iNkundla ePhakamileyo yeLizwe lase Washington inike isigqibo esibalulekileyo esijolise ekusombululeni umba wocalucalulo ngokobuhlanga kwiinkqubo zenkundla yoluntu. Isigqibo, UHenderson v Thompson, iphinda ithethe ngesigwebo esifanayo esivela kwiNkundla esasisebenza kwiinkqubo zenkundla yolwaphulo-mthetho (Jonga: Urhulumente v. Zamora).


Yintoni entsha malunga Henderson isigqibo?

Ngaphambi kwesi sigwebo, Washington Imithetho yenkundla igxininise ukuba luxanduva lwe iqela elityholayo ukungqina ukuba ucalucalulo ngokobuhlanga luphembelele iinkqubo zenkundla yoluntu okanye izigwebo zejaji. Ngokwahlukileyo koko, Henderson Isigqibo sigqiba kwelokuba xa umntu okwinkqubo yembambano etyhola omnye umntu ngokukhetha icala, luxanduva lwakhe iqela elityholwayo ukungqina ukuba bekungekho cala linjalo. Olu lutshintsho olukhulu kuba lutshintsha umthwalo ukusuka ekubeni “kubungqina bokuba isiphumo besiqhutywa lucalucalulo” ukuya ekubeni “kubungqina ukuba besingaqhutywa lucalucalulo”.


Imvelaphi ye UHenderson v Thompson ityala:

Iqale njani?  Kule meko, uJanelle Henderson, umfazi omnyama, kunye noAlicia Thompson, umfazi omhlophe, babebandakanyeke kwingozi yemoto. UThompson uvumile ukuba unecala ngale ngozi kodwa akazange anikezele ngembuyekezo kuHenderson ngenxa yokwenzakala kwakhe. UHenderson uthi imeko yakhe yangaphambili yayimbi kakhulu yile ngozi waza wafaka isicelo somonakalo.

Kwenzeke ntoni kwityala?  Ngexesha letyala, iqela likaThomson lokukhusela lahlasela ukuthembeka kukaHenderson kunye negqwetha lakhe - naye owayengumfazi omnyama - ngolwimi olwalubiza amagama abonisa ucalucalulo ngokobuhlanga kwaye lucebisa ukungafaneleki phakathi kukaHenderson namangqina akhe amnyama.

Ijaji ligqibe ngelithini?  Ijaji libuyisele isigwebo se-$9,200 kuphela kuHenderson.

Waphendula njani uHenderson?  UHenderson utshintshele kwityala elitsha okanye isongezo (ichazwa njengonyuso lwentlawulo yomonakalo yinkundla yejaji, nto leyo inkundla eyibona ingonelanga) ngesizathu sokuba izibheno eziphindaphindwayo zokukhetha uhlanga zichaphazele isigwebo.

Inkundla yamatyala yasabela njani kwisicelo sikaHenderson?  Inkundla yamatyala ayizange ivume nokuva ubungqina kweso sicelo. Endaweni yoko, inkundla yathi ayinakufuna ukuba amagqwetha ayeke ukusebenzisa ulwimi oluhambelana nobungqina obukweli tyala, nokuba kwezinye iimeko ulwimi lunentsingiselo yobuhlanga.


Zeziphi izinto ezibalulekileyo kwisigqibo seNkundla ePhakamileyo yaseWA kwi Henderson?

Kwi Henderson isigqibo, Washington INkundla ePhakamileyo yeLizwe igwebe ukuba uHenderson usebenzise ngokufanelekileyo i-CR 59(a)(9), ethi isigwebo esichatshazelwa kukucalucalulwa ngokobuhlanga asihambelani nobulungisa obuqinileyo kwaye sifuna ityala elitsha.

Ngaphezu koko, iNkundla igwebe ngelithi “[xa] ummangalelwa wezomthetho esenza umbono wokuqala obonisa ngokwaneleyo ukuba agqibe kwelokuba kukho ucalucalulo ngokobuhlanga phantsi kwalo mgangatho, inkundla kumele unikezele ngengxoxo yobungqina ukuze kuchongwe ukuba ityala elitsha liyafuneka na” (Ugxininiso longeziwe.) Henderson, 19. Ikwagwebe ngelithi ekumiseleni ukuba ityala lobungqina lifanele livunywe na, iinjongo zommangalelwa okanye isiphakamiso senkundla sokuba kukho nako kusenokuchazwa ezinye iindlela zokuziphatha ezibangelwa luhlanga kuloo sigqibo.

Ekugqibeleni, iNkundla yagweba ngelithi kuloo ngxoxo, “inkundla yamatyala mayicinge ukuba ukukhetha ngokobuhlanga kuchaphazele isigwebo, kwaye iqela elixhamlayo kukukhetha ngokobuhlanga okutyholwayo linoxanduva lokungqina ukuba lenze njalo.” hayi. " UHenderson, oneminyaka eli-19 ubudala.


Zeziphi iintlobo “zezibheno zocalucalulo ngokobuhlanga” iNkundla ezivumile ukuba zenzekile kwityala likaHenderson?

  • Igqwetha likaThompson liphindaphinde lathi uHenderson “ungumntu ophikisanayo nothanda ukulwa” kubungqina bakhe. Inkundla ivumile ukuba la magama “avuselela ingcamango eyingozi ‘yomfazi omnyama onomsindo’.” Henderson,
  • Igqwetha likaThompson liphindaphinde ukuthelekisa indlela uHenderson achazwa ngayo noThompson, awamchaza “njengomntu owoyikisayo novakalelwa yimvakalelo”.
  • Kwingxoxo zokugqibela, igqwetha likaThompson likhankanye iingcamango zocalucalulo ngokobuhlanga ngabafazi abamnyama njengezingathembekanga kwaye zishukunyiswa ngumnqweno wokufumana imali engenayo. Igqwetha likaThompson lathi uHenderson wayebaxa okanye eqamba ukwenzakala kwakhe. Inkundla yagqiba kwelokuba le ngxoxo idlale kwiingcamango ezimbi nezingeyonyani malunga nabafazi abamnyama abangathembekanga, abavilaphayo, abakhohlisayo, nabanyolukileyo. Henderson,
  • Igqwetha likaThompson lichaze ubungqina bamangqina amathathu amnyama kaHenderson “njengobunocalucalulo ngokwendalo”.
  • Igqwetha likaThompson lithe amangqina amnyama adibene ukuze axoke egameni lommangali omnyama. Henderson,
  • Igqwetha likaThompson licebise ukuba uHenderson wayenobudlelwane obungafanelekanga nogqirha wakhe wengqondo obunokumenza axoke ngenxa yakhe. Henderson,
  • Ijaji kwityala likaHenderson lejaji lithe ijaji lifuna uHenderson aphume enkundleni ngaphambi kokuba baphume kwigumbi lejaji ukuze banike isigwebo sabo.

Ukuba ndicinga ukuba ukucalucalulwa ngokobuhlanga kuyichaphazela kakubi imeko yomthengi wam, ndingenza ntoni? Injani le nkqubo?

Kulula: Yizise enkundleni.  Umthwalo wobungqina usemagxeni otyholwayo, omele abonise ukuba bekungekho bandlululo ngokobuhlanga.


isiphelo

Esi sigwebo besisele siza kudala. Kuye kwakho amaxesha amaninzi kwiminyaka apho amagqwetha ayebhenela ekucalucaluleni ngokobuhlanga (kwaye ngamanye amaxesha amajaji ayevumelana nako) ngaphandle kokuthetha ngokuthe ngqo. Baye basebenzisa (njengakwi Henderson) amagama athile kwaye benza izityholo ezithile ezenza kwaba nzima kwelinye iqela ukungqina injongo yabo. Ngoku ekubeni umthwalo utshintshile, nangona kunjalo, kuya kwenza kube nzima kakhulu ukuba ukubhenela kucalucalulo lobuhlanga kwenzeke, kwaye xa besenza njalo, baya kwaziswa elubala kwaye umoni uya kubanjwa uxanduva. Olu luloyiso kungekuphela nje kubantu abanombala, kodwa nakubani na omela ubulungisa kwi Washington inkqubo yenkundla karhulumente.


Umxhasi

Ukuze ufumane ulwazi oluthe kratya ngezihloko ezixutyushwayo kolu hlaziyo lwezomthetho, nceda ungathandabuzi ukuqhagamshelana nombhali walo:

James Goodba  | Igqwetha
Umnini-zabelo kwi-GLP Attorneys

206.448.1992  |  Cofa apha ukuze ufunde okungakumbi ngoJames.


isikhanyeli

Ulwazi oluqulethwe kolu hlaziyo lunikezelwe ngeenjongo zolwazi kuphela. Nceda unxibelelane negqwetha lakho ukuze ufumane ingcebiso ngayo nayiphi na imiba ethile yomthetho.