I-Civil 172020

Chofoza lapha ukuze uthole inguqulo elungele ukuphrinta.


Isingeniso

Ngomhlaka-20 Okthoba 2022, iNkantolo Ephakeme Yombuso wase Washington ikhiphe isinqumo esibalulekile esihlose ukubhekana nodaba lokucwasa ngokohlanga ezinqubweni zenkantolo yomphakathi. Isinqumo, UHenderson v. Thompson, inweba isinqumo esifanayo esivela eNkantolo esasisebenza ezinqubweni zenkantolo yobugebengu (Bheka: UMbuso v. Zamora).


Yini entsha mayelana ne- Henderson isinqumo?

Ngaphambi kwalesi sinqumo, Washington imithetho yenkantolo yagcizelela ukuthi kwakuyisibopho sika iqembu elimangalelayo ukufakazela ukuthi ubandlululo lobuhlanga luthonye izinqubo zenkantolo yomphakathi noma izinqumo zamajaji. Ngokuphambene nalokho, Henderson Isinqumo siphetha ngokuthi uma umuntu obhekene necala lombango esola omunye umuntu ngokubandlulula, kungumthwalo wemfanelo womthetho. iqembu elisolwayo ukufakazela ukuthi bekungekho ukucwasa okunjalo. Lolu ushintsho olukhulu ngoba lususa umthwalo ekubeni “ubufakazi bokuthi umphumela wawushukunyiswa ngokobuhlanga” uye ekubeni “ubufakazi bokuthi kwakungenjalo”.


Isizinda se- UHenderson v. Thompson icala:

Kwaqala kanjani?  Kulokhu, uJanelle Henderson, owesifazane omnyama, no-Alicia Thompson, owesifazane omhlophe, babehileleke engozini yemoto. UThompson uvumile ukuthi unecala ngale ngozi kodwa akazange anikeze isinxephezelo sokukhokhela uHenderson ngokulimala kwakhe. UHenderson uthe isimo sakhe sangaphambilini sabhebhethekiswa kakhulu yile ngozi futhi wafaka isicelo somonakalo.

Kwenzekani ecaleni?  Ngesikhathi secala, ithimba labameli bakaThomson lahlasela ukwethembeka kukaHenderson kanye nommeli wakhe - naye ongowesifazane omnyama - ngolimi olwalubiza amagama acwasa ngokobuhlanga futhi lwaphakamisa ukungafaneleki phakathi kukaHenderson nofakazi bakhe abamnyama.

Ijaji lanquma ukuthini?  Ijaji libuyisele isinqumo sikaHenderson esingu-$9,200 kuphela.

Wasabela kanjani uHenderson?  UHenderson uthuthele icala elisha noma okungeziwe (okuchazwa njengokukhushulwa yinkantolo yejaji ukunikezwa kwenhlawulo okuyinto inkantolo ebona inganele) ngesizathu sokuthi ukudlulisa amacala okuphindaphindiwe kobandlululo ngokohlanga kuthinte isinqumo.

Inkantolo yamacala yasabela kanjani esicelweni sikaHenderson?  Inkantolo yokuqala ayizange inikeze ngisho nokulalelwa kobufakazi kuleso sicelo. Esikhundleni salokho inkantolo yathi ayinakudinga “abameli ukuba bayeke ukusebenzisa ulimi oluhlobene nobufakazi ecaleni, noma ngabe kwezinye izimo ulimi lunezincazelo zobuhlanga.”


Yiziphi izinto ezibalulekile esinqumweni seNkantolo Ephakeme yase-WA ku Henderson?

In the Henderson isinqumo, Washington INkantolo Ephakeme Yombuso inqume ukuthi uHenderson usebenzise ngokufanele i-CR 59(a)(9), ethi isinqumo esithintwa ukucwasa ngokohlanga asihambisani nobulungiswa obukhulu futhi sidinga ukuqulwa kwecala elisha.

Ngaphezu kwalokho, iNkantolo yanquma ukuthi “[uma] ummangalelwa enza umbono wokuqala obonisa okwanele ukudweba isiphetho sobandlululo lobuhlanga ngaphansi kwalesi simiso, inkantolo kumele ukunikeza ukulalelwa kobufakazi ukuze kunqunywe ukuthi ngabe icala elisha liyafuneka yini” (Kugcizelelwe.) Henderson, 19. Yaphinde yanquma ukuthi ekunqumeni ukuthi kufanele yini kuvunyelwe ukuqulwa kwecala lobufakazi, izinhloso zommeleli osolwayo noma isiphakamiso senkantolo sokuthi kukhona ayengakwenza kungaba ukuhumusha okunye ngendaba yokuziphatha okubangelwa ubandlululo kuleso sinqumo.

Ekugcineni, iNkantolo yanquma ukuthi kulelo cala, “inkantolo yecala kufanele icabange ukuthi ubandlululo lobuhlanga luthinte isinqumo, futhi iqembu elizuzayo kubandlululo lobuhlanga olusolwayo linomthwalo wokufakazela ukuthi lwenze kanjalo.” hhayi. " UHenderson, oneminyaka engu-19.


Yiziphi izinhlobo “zokudlulisa icala lokucwasa ngokohlanga” iNkantolo eyazi ukuthi zenzekile ecaleni likaHenderson?

  • Ummeli kaThompson uchaze uHenderson ngokuphindaphindiwe njengomuntu “ophikisanayo futhi “olwa” ebufakazini bakhe. Inkantolo ivumile ukuthi la magama “avusa umbono oyingozi ‘wowesifazane omnyama othukuthele’.” Henderson,
  • Ummeli kaThompson uphindaphinde ukuqhathanisa lokho kuchazwa kukaHenderson noThompson, amchaza ngokuthi “uyesabeka futhi uthinta imizwa”.
  • Ezimpikiswaneni zokugcina, ummeli kaThompson ubhekisele emibonweni yobandlululo ngabesifazane abamnyama njengengathembekile futhi eshukunyiswa yisifiso sokuthola inzuzo yezezimali engayitholanga. Ummeli kaThompson uphikise ngokuthi uHenderson wayeyihaba noma eqamba amanga ngokulimala kwakhe. Inkantolo yaphetha ngokuthi le mpikiswano idlale emibonweni emibi nengamanga mayelana nabesifazane abamnyama abangathembekile, abavilaphayo, abakhohlisayo, nabahahayo. Henderson,
  • Ummeli kaThompson uchaze ubufakazi bofakazi abathathu abamnyama bakaHenderson “njengobunobandlululo ngokwemvelo”.
  • Ummeli kaThompson uveze ukuthi ofakazi abamnyama bahlangane ndawonye ukuqamba amanga egameni lommangali omnyama. Henderson,
  • Ummeli kaThompson uphakamise ukuthi uHenderson wayenobuhlobo obungafanele nodokotela wakhe we-chiropractor obungamenza aqambe amanga ngenxa yakhe. Henderson,
  • Ijaji ecaleni likaHenderson lejaji lithe ijaji lifuna uHenderson aphume enkantolo ngaphambi kokuba baphume egumbini lejaji ukuze bakhiphe isinqumo sabo.

Uma ngisola ukuthi ubandlululo ngokohlanga luthinta kabi icala leklayenti lami, kufanele ngenzenjani? Inqubo ibukeka kanjani?

Kulula: Yilethe enkantolo.  Umthwalo wobufakazi usezandleni zomuntu osolwayo, okumele afakazele ukuthi bekungekho ukucwasa ngokohlanga.


Isiphetho

Lesi sinqumo besisesikhathi eside sifika. Kube nezimo eziningi eminyakeni edlule lapho abameli bekhalaza ngokucwasa ngokohlanga (kanye namajaji ngezinye izikhathi behambisana nakho) ngaphandle kokuphuma basho kanjalo ngqo. Basebenzise (njengaku- Henderson) amagama athile futhi benza izinsolo ezithile ezenza kwaba nzima ngolunye uhlangothi ukufakazela inhloso yazo. Manje njengoba umthwalo usushintshile, nokho, kuzokwenza kube lula kakhulu ukuthi ukunxenxa ubandlululo ngokobuhlanga kwenzeke, futhi uma kwenzeka, kuzovezwa obala futhi umenzi wobubi uzolandisa. Lokhu kuwukunqoba hhayi nje kwabantu abanombala, kodwa nanoma ubani omelela ubulungiswa Washington uhlelo lwenkantolo yesifundazwe.


Umhlanganyeli

Ukuze uthole ulwazi olwengeziwe ngezihloko okuxoxwe ngazo kulesi sibuyekezo sezomthetho, sicela ungangabazi ukuxhumana nombhali waso:

James GoodIng  | Ummeli
Umnikazi wamasheya e-GLP Attorneys

206.448.1992  |  Chofoza lapha ukuze ufunde kabanzi ngoJames.


Disclaimer

Ulwazi oluqukethwe kulesi sibuyekezo luhlinzekwa ngezinjongo zolwazi kuphela. Sicela uxhumane nommeli wakho ukuze uthole iseluleko nganoma yiluphi udaba oluthile lwezomthetho.