By John D. Webber | Managing Shareholder | GLP Attorneys in Seattle, Washington

Healthcare providers across Washington are telling us the same three things:

  1. They are being asked to cut their bills, often late in the case and with little explanation.
  2. They are waiting months for payment, or not getting paid at all.
  3. They can’t find out what’s happening with a patient’s case, or even which firm is handling it.

When we dig into these stories, a pattern often appears. The patient responded to an ad or text, signed with an out-of-state law firm or marketing company, and the case was then sold to a law firm based in Washington. Somewhere along the way, the provider who has been treating the patient for months dropped out of the picture.

Not every out-of-state firm works this way, and many referrals are handled properly. But if you treat injured patients, it helps to understand how case brokering works, what the rules require, and how to protect your practice and your patients.

How case brokering works
Many injury ads are not placed by the law firm that will handle the case. A typical path looks like this:

  1. A marketing company runs the ad or text. It may use a firm-sounding name, a local phone number and Washington imagery, but it isn’t a law firm, and it isn’t in Washington.
  2. It signs up the injured person. It collects the accident details, injuries, insurance information and contact details.
  3. It sends the person to a provider in its “network.” The company chooses the clinic, not the patient or their own doctor. Network providers may have agreed to terms such as lien treatment, fee reductions or other conditions to stay in the network.
  4. It sells the case to a licensed attorney. The buyer may be a Washington firm or an out-of-state firm working through Washington counsel. The attorney may never have met the client before the case arrives. When several firms bid, this is sometimes called “auctioning” a case.

The patient often believes the company that answered the phone is their law firm. In fact the treatment decision and the choice of lawyer were both made by a business whose income depends on moving cases, not on the patient’s recovery.

At each handoff, information gets lost, and providers are the easiest thing to lose. The firm on the file may not know about your lien or letter of protection, may never have spoken with your office, and may be managing hundreds of cases from a different time zone.

Why the provider relationship suffers
A local firm depends on its reputation with local providers. It sees the same clinics month after month and has every reason to treat them fairly. A high-volume model built on purchased cases has different incentives. Settling fast and at volume can matter more than full value for the patient. Unpaid provider balances are a cost to be negotiated down, not a relationship to protect.

The three problems providers report
1. Being asked to reduce bills
Reduction requests aren’t always unreasonable. When the at-fault driver carries only Washington’s minimum $25,000 in per person liability coverage and the patient has serious injuries, everyone may need to take less so the patient isn’t left with nothing.

The concern is when reductions become routine. Warning signs:

  • The request comes at the very end, after the case has already settled. And the case has settled for less than it should have.
  • No one explains why: no policy limits, no settlement amount, no breakdown of how other bills are being handled.
  • The same percentage cut is requested on every case, regardless of the facts.
  • Your office is told to accept by a deadline or risk getting nothing.
  • The attorney asks you to take less but won’t reduce their own fee.

That last point deserves attention. For a firm juggling a high volume of cases, asking every provider to cut their bill can be a shortcut. Instead of doing the work to build and prove the full value of the case, the firm makes the numbers work by shrinking everyone else’s share. When a reduction is truly needed, a firm that’s doing its job shares the sacrifice, including its own fee.

You can ask for the information behind a request before agreeing to it. A firm acting in good faith should be able to explain the numbers, with the patient’s permission.

2. Not getting paid
Payment problems usually start with a lost handoff. Your lien notice went to the marketing company or the first firm, and the firm that settled the case never had it. Or the case moved firms, and no one updated the ledger. By the time you learn the case settled, the money may already be distributed.

3. Not being kept informed
Providers often learn about a settlement, a firm change, or a dropped case months after the fact. Without updates, you can’t plan treatment, manage your balance or answer your patient’s questions. Silence is often the first sign that a case has changed hands.

What Washington’s rules require
Referrals, co-counsel and out-of-state firms are all legal when the rules are followed. Knowing the basics helps you spot when something is off.

  • Fee splits need the client’s written consent. When lawyers at different firms divide a fee, the split must reflect each lawyer’s work or joint responsibility. The client must agree to each lawyer’s share in writing, and the total fee must be reasonable.
  • The lawyers must be licensed to practice here. Out-of-state lawyers need Washington authorization or must properly associate with Washington counsel. A Washington phone number in an ad is not a Washington lawyer. You can check any attorney in the WSBA Legal Directory.
  • Ads and texts cannot be misleading. That includes leaving out the fact that the advertiser won’t be the one handling the case.
  • Contingency fee agreements must be in writing. They must explain how the fee is calculated and how expenses are handled.
  • Your patient can hire a new (truly) local attorney at any time. The new attorney can take over the case and deal with the prior attorney.

These rules protect the client. They don’t directly protect your bill, which is why your own processes matter.

When patients are steered away from your clinic
If your clinic isn’t part of one of these networks, the problem may look different: injured patients who would naturally come to you end up somewhere else. It usually happens quietly. A patient is hurt in a crash, sees an ad and calls. The company that answers tells them where to get treatment. Sometimes it says their regular provider “doesn’t handle injury cases” or “won’t wait for payment.” Sometimes it offers rides or promises no out-of-pocket cost. The patient goes where they are told, often without realizing they had a choice.

This matters beyond lost visits. A patient pulled away from a provider who knows their history can lose continuity of care. The new clinic was chosen by a business, not by the patient or their doctor.

Signs patients are being steered

  • An established patient is in a crash, and you later learn they’re being treated somewhere else.
  • A patient says their “lawyer” or “case manager” told them where they have to go.
  • You get a records request from another clinic soon after a patient contacts a law firm or injury hotline.
  • A patient cannot name their attorney, only a company name or an 800 number.
  • A patient believes they must switch clinics to keep their case.
  • New-patient calls after car crashes drop while injury ads in your area increase.

What you can do

  • Tell patients they choose their provider. Put it in your intake paperwork and on a sign at the front desk: “You choose your healthcare provider. A lawyer or marketing company can’t require you to change clinics.”
  •  Ask every new injury patient three questions at intake: How did you find us? Do you have a lawyer? Who is it?
  • Train your front desk to listen for steering. When a patient mentions being told where to go, note it in the chart and make sure they know they have a choice.
  • Remove the reasons patients switch. Explain clearly how PIP, health insurance and liens work at your clinic, so “no upfront cost” isn’t the only reason a patient leaves.
  •  Talk about continuity of care. Patients may not realize that switching providers mid-treatment can interrupt their recovery. Gaps or changes in treatment can also raise questions in an injury claim.
  • Point patients to help if they were misled. A patient who believes a lawyer misled them can ask the lawyer for answers in writing or contact the Washington State Bar Association.
  • Work with firms that respect patient choice. Local firms that let clients keep their own providers protect both your relationships and your patients’ care.

Protecting your practice
Before treatment starts

  • Get the responsible attorney’s name, the firm, the firm’s location and a direct contact for billing. A marketing company’s name or a 1-800 number isn’t enough.
  • Confirm the attorney is licensed in Washington, or ask who the Washington co-counsel is.
  • Send your lien notice or letter of protection to the firm that actually has the file, and ask for written confirmation it was received

While the case is open

  • Ask to be notified in writing if the case moves to another firm.
  • Re-confirm representation before major treatment and every few months.
  • Release records only to the firm named in a current patient authorization. Be cautious with requests from intake or marketing companies.
  • If a case goes quiet, call. Silence often means the case has moved.

At settlement

  • If you’re asked to reduce your bill, ask for the reason: policy limits, the settlement amount and how other bills are being treated.
  • Get any agreed reduction in writing, including the payment date.
  • Don’t accept a reduction on a deadline you can’t verify.

Questions to ask any firm

  1. Who is the attorney responsible for this case, and where are they located?
  2. Is your firm handling the case through resolution, or is another firm involved?
  3. Who do we contact about our balance, and how quickly do you respond?
  4. Have you received our lien notice or letter of protection?
  5. Will you notify us if the case is referred or the firm changes?
  6. How do you handle provider balances at settlement?

Warning signs

  • No one can name the attorney responsible for the case.
  • The firm is out of state and can’t name its Washington counsel.
  • Different businesses contact your office about the same patient.
  • Records requests come from a company that isn’t a law firm.
  • Reduction requests arrive after settlement, with no explanation.
  • Calls and emails go unanswered for weeks.

None of these proves misconduct on its own. They do justify getting clear answers before you extend more treatment on a lien.

What providers should expect from a law firm
You treat the patient for months, often without payment up front, because you trust the case will be handled responsibly. In return, you should be able to expect:

  • A named attorney and a real contact person who answers within a reasonable time
  • Confirmation that your lien or letter of protection was received
  • Notice if the case changes firms
  • Periodic updates on where the case stands, with the patient’s permission
  • An honest explanation, early, if a reduction may be needed, rather than a surprise after settlement
  • Prompt payment once the case resolves

How GLP Attorneys works with providers
GLP Attorneys is a proud Washington firm with local offices and local attorneys. We support our local communities every day. We value long-term relationships with the providers who care for our clients. You can always contact an attorney directly for balance questions, lien confirmations and case status. If you have questions about a patient’s case, or about how we work with providers, contact your local GLP Attorneys’ office or call 800-273-5005.